Thanksgiving has always been a time to celebrate family, but for me, this year felt more like walking into a battlefield I didn’t sign up for. What began as a joke about skipping my sister-in-law Amy’s vegetarian Thanksgiving quickly escalated into my husband Jeremy threatening divorce. What I uncovered in the days that followed revealed a deeper, more painful betrayal that shook the foundations of our marriage.

It all started with Amy’s text: she announced she’d be hosting Thanksgiving and declared it would be strictly vegetarian. “No meat or animal products allowed!” she wrote. “Anyone who doesn’t respect this rule will be kicked out. Trust me, you won’t even miss them once you try my Tofurky roast!” Her self-righteous tone practically jumped off the screen.

I couldn’t help but laugh as I read it. “Can you believe this?” I said to Jeremy, expecting him to laugh along with me. Instead, he gave me a sharp look that stopped me mid-chuckle.

“It’s just one meal, Belinda,” he said, his voice low and tense. “You can handle it.”

“Of course I can,” I shot back. “I just don’t want to.”

Jeremy’s frustration was immediate. “Why does everything with Amy have to be such a big deal? It’s a family holiday, and it’s important to her. Can’t you do this to make her happy?”

I crossed my arms, trying to keep the hurt out of my voice. “Because it’s not about the food, Jeremy. Amy always takes control and expects everyone to bend to her will. I’m tired of it.” I suggested we spend Thanksgiving at home instead, just the two of us, enjoying a quiet dinner.

His response was like a slap in the face. “If you can’t support my family, maybe you shouldn’t be part of it anymore.”

“Divorce? Over one dinner?” I asked, my voice trembling with shock and anger. He muttered something about support and walked away, leaving me reeling.

The days leading up to Thanksgiving were tense. Jeremy was distant, coming home late and retreating into himself. Money, too, had become a strange issue. I noticed him scrutinizing our bank statements more than usual, his brow furrowed in worry.

@threadtalkpodcast AITA for not going to Vegan Thanksgiving? #reddit #aita #tifu #redditstory #redditstories #threadtalk #threadtalkpodcast #podcast #redditreadings ♬ original sound – ThreadTalk Podcast

One night, after he went to bed, I opened our joint account on my laptop. Regular withdrawals labeled “medical expenses” caught my eye. A quick search revealed the doctor was a psychologist. My stomach twisted. Was Jeremy in therapy? Why hadn’t he told me?

The next evening, I asked him directly. His answer was vague and evasive. “It’s been a rough year,” he said, avoiding my gaze. But his words felt off, and I couldn’t shake the feeling he was hiding something.

Then, a few nights before Thanksgiving, I woke to the sound of his voice in the living room. Tiptoeing to the doorway, I listened.

“I told you I’d handle it,” he said, his tone soft, almost tender. “You don’t have to worry… Goodnight, Amy.”

My heart dropped. Amy. Of course, it was her.

The next morning, I confronted him. “Why are you so committed to Amy?” I asked, my voice tight with frustration. “The late-night calls, the money, the secrets—what are you hiding?”

Jeremy looked trapped, his shoulders slumping under the weight of his secrets. Finally, he sighed. “Amy has bipolar disorder. It got really bad a few years ago, and she was hospitalized. When she got out, I was the only one she trusted. I’ve been helping her ever since.”

His confession hit me like a wave, each word unraveling my understanding of him. He admitted the “medical expenses” were for her therapy and other needs.

“Why didn’t you tell me?” I asked, my voice shaking. “Do you have any idea what keeping this secret has done to us?”

“I didn’t want you to think less of her,” he said. “Or of me. I thought I was protecting her.”

“But at what cost, Jeremy? You’ve put her above our marriage. You’re so busy protecting Amy that you’re willing to lose me over a Thanksgiving dinner.”

He looked at me, his face full of regret. “I didn’t realize it would come to this,” he said quietly.

“Well, it has,” I replied. “You need to choose—between hiding the truth and being honest. Between enabling Amy’s behavior and setting boundaries. Between being her caretaker and being my partner.”

Jeremy hesitated, fear etched into his expression. “What if setting boundaries makes her worse?” he asked.

“What if it doesn’t?” I countered. “What if she’s stronger than you think? She might surprise you.”

The silence that followed felt like an eternity. Finally, Jeremy nodded. “I’ll try,” he said.

But as I looked at him, I couldn’t shake the feeling that we were at an impasse. The cracks in our marriage were too deep to ignore, and I wasn’t sure if we could repair them. Thanksgiving was just the tip of the iceberg, and the truth beneath it all was far more complicated than I ever imagined.